Interview in Reverse
One person knows the ending of a harmless little mystery. Investigators work backward by asking questions that can be answered in three ways.

Set the scene
Read the puzzle aloud: “A host set six plates for five guests. Nobody else ate. By dessert all six plates had been used.” Secret answer: one plate held the shared bread.
How to play
- Investigators take turns asking one factual question, such as “Was the extra plate used before dessert?” The narrator answers yes, no or irrelevant based on the slip.
- After five questions pause for a recap. If an equally valid explanation appears, record it as an alternative and ask what fact would distinguish it from the written solution.
- Win together by describing the serving plate within twelve questions. If time runs out, read the slip and let players identify the assumption that wasted the most questions.
Host’s note
Accept “a communal serving plate” as the core solution; the exact food matters only if the group requested a tighter puzzle.
Try a variation
Give groups two minutes to invent a second puzzle from an ordinary double use, such as a chair holding coats. Another group checks whether its answer really fits.
More in this collection
The Last Lantern
A festival lantern disappeared between a rehearsal and the audience's arrival. Read four short parts and reconstruct its journey before the curtain rises.
MysteryThe Borrowed Landmark
Everyone describes the same place except the visitor, who has only a category to go on. Specific memories can give away the location.
MysteryArchive After Hours
A mixed-up closing log contains enough information to order four errands. Nobody may pass a clue slip across the table.